Amazing place! Known as the Greatest spot on Earth. The kosher dill pickle pizza is to die for. The cashier is super friendly and very sweet. The owner sings and speaks in the most Beautiful Napolitano accent. Great people great food
- Paul Cerminara

Best Philly cheesesteaks and pizza in the area. Cozy atmosphere, friendly folks!
- michael burroughs

Food was amazing,service was great and atmosphere was very nice and enjoyable.Deff will be going again Food:
- SHELLIE REYNOLDS

Amazing pizza and amazing service! We came in after they closed the dining room and they insisted they serve us anyways. We got a medium pepperoni pizza and it was very substantial for the price, as well as very good. Highly recommend for anyone in the area you won’t be disappointed.
- Gabriel Ryan

Mystic Pizza is the best pizza place around! Their pizza is amazing, and I like a lot of their other foods as well. There was NEVER a time where I had seen anyone in my family disappointed and throwing out a half eaten dish from this place. Mystic Pizza has great food that is extremely delicious!!!
- Jennifer Fasy

My husband and I order from here frequently. Family owned and operated, very friendly customer service, great pizza, subs and Italian in general. Great people making great food! That's what it's all about folks!🇮🇹🍝🍕🇺🇲
- T. Veres

Some of the most wonderful people making the most delicious pizza on the planet!
- Mark Hills

The food is absolutely worth the price! Haven’t had a bad experience will recommend to all neighbors and friends!
- Daniel Lotito

Walked in and right away my wife and I were greated ! We had a great sandwich ! The pizza looked really yummy ! This was is very inviting. They use homemade ingredients as explained . I can't wait to try there pizza !! The inside very nice ! Plenty of parking . It's a nice location ! Looking so fwd to eating there. Thank you for a great sandwich and conversation.
- Brad

This has to be far the best pizza place around, the food is amazing, staff is always friendly and welcoming. Can’t go wrong with anything you order. You have to try it, trust me you won’t be disappointed.
- Salvatore M

Mystic Pizza is the best. Love the people and the food, delicious 😋
- Lynn Hansen

The service was good nice atmosphere clean restaurant but the veal was a little over cooked on the edges
- Steve Coffman

Great atmosphere and good friendly people! The food is delicious and always fresh! Run and owned by a family that as soon as you are seated, one of them will great you with a friendly smile ... very fussy with their food entrees to be sure everything is perfect... you never have to worry about it not being g fresh and hot...love this place...best kept secret...and they deliver!!!!!! Treat yourself...you will not be sorry....
- Erik Christensen

Hands down the best Italian food! This family establishment brings Italy to New Jersey! Clean, friendly, attentive, and delicious! Grab a quick slice or have them prepare an authentic Italian dinner but don't leave without trying their marinara sauce!!!
- James Creveling

If you want great food, friendly atmosphere, and a awesome, place to eat, then try Mystic Island Pizza You will enjoy anything you order from the menu, and they will make sure of that. If you have a health problem and cant eat something they will do their best to accommodate you with a smile. Everyone is friendly and makes you feel welcome. We love it there, great place to have lunch or dinner with friends.
- Ginger Fairhurst

Clean, friendly, Excellent pizza and authentic Italian foods. It's family owned and operated which makes it feel like home from your very first visit. We're new to the area but we found our Italian restaurant before we found our new house.... THIS IS IT!!!!
- Andre Benacchio

Hands down this is the most consistent pizzeria from Barnegat all the way down to Galloway! I’m a Jersey City/Bayonne guy so I’m very picky on my Italian restaurants! So for starters they have the most absolute fantastic mussels I’ve ever eaten, even better than up top! Also the marinara forget about it, it’s unreal! I’ve been down here for almost a year and I let this place slip by under the radar. What a mistake! You want some tasty food this is the spot! Chicken parm is phenomenal, chicken cutlet sandwich is delicious, the cheesesteaks are slamming! This joint is the TRUTH!!
- Michael O

Incredibly nice staff! Stopped in on our vacation and Would absolutely recommend it and stop again if so. Thanks for your hospitality!
- Vanessa Evenson

Love this place!!! Family run, best food in town Celeste is amazing love her❤ i was raised in mystic everytime i come up for a visit its definitely my first stop got to have that great jersey pie. And theirs is the best.❤🍕🍕
- debra long

There pizzas are out of this world, always fresh dough, fresh ingredients, and a superb staff, friendy, courteous and accommodating. Recently moved a family came from Va. Ca, and phila. Pa i bought the pizza home for all there hsrd work, and there was not a crust left. Now when my family visits they cannit wait to havr me order, pies from Mystic Island Pizza.
- kim tait

I have to say, this is the best pizza! I've had a lot of pizza 🍕 from different places and Mystic is the best!
- Anne Distefano

Amazing pizza, Amazing food, Amazing Amazing people. Great atmosphere for a nice dinner. Employees were very nice and explained the menu well. Tried the vodka sauce on their recommendation and loved it!
- Judy Galayda