Mystic Island Pizza and Ristorante Mystic IslandPizza & Ristorante Order Online
Specialty pizzas in the window, one with chicken and ranch and one with buffalo chicken
From our oven

Pies from dough we make ourselves.

Breaded chicken cutlet over penne in pink vodka sauce
Dinner plates

Chicken over penne in vodka sauce.

Steak sandwich from the menu
Steak house

Cheesesteaks, hot and loaded.

Wings and appetizers
To share

Wings hot or dry. Sides to share.

Antipasto salad with rolled ham, salami, and fresh mozzarella
From the cold case

Salads, antipasto, and dinner.

Order

Little Egg Harbor

Family owned. We are the makers, bakers, and order takers.

Mystic Island Pizza is a neighborhood pizzeria and ristorante on Radio Road. The dough is ours. The marinara is made from scratch. Veggies are grown here when they are in season. We deliver, and we cook for the table.

Read the menu

House pies

Cheese, Sicilian, grandma, and the Mystic Special. Build a 14, 16, or 18 inch, or a gluten-free 12.

See pizza

Dinner plates

Chicken and eggplant parm, shrimp fra diavolo, baked ziti, and vodka sauce over pasta, served with bread.

See entrees

Cater with Connie

Just about every dish can travel. Call and she will size the food to the people.

Plan a party

From Google

Five stars, said plainly.

★★★★★

Some of the most wonderful people making the most delicious pizza on the planet.

Mark Hills
★★★★★

Hands down the best Italian food. This family establishment brings Italy to New Jersey. Don't leave without trying their marinara.

James Creveling
★★★★★

There is something about their crust that is absolutely delectable. The owner is high energy and loves his patrons.

Alexandria Russell

All 18 reviews